Chicago Botanic Garden ornamental plant breeder Justin Lombardoni used a July session at the Perennial Plant Association’s National Symposium in East Lansing, MI, to explain how the garden’s perennial breeding program differs from for-profit industry counterparts. He spoke during a session featuring breeders discussing their current work. According to Lombardoni, the Chicago Botanic Garden program is, to his knowledge, the only breeding program at a botanic garden in the country.
As part of a nonprofit institution, the program targets genera and traits differently from commercial operations, Lombardoni said. Its small size and limited resources mean it cannot compete head-to-head with larger commercial breeding programs, he added. Even if it could, many mainstream genera are already crowded with dozens or hundreds of cultivars. He questioned whether the market needs another Echinacea or Hosta when comparatively esoteric genera still have untapped potential.
Native plants and invasive risk
When selecting genera, the program prioritizes natives, though not exclusively. Lombardoni noted that people apply different standards when deciding whether a species is native—whether it must grow in their county, state, or region. He prefers the regional category because plants do not recognize artificial borders between counties or states, especially when those borders lack physical barriers to spread.
For exotic genera, the program considers two seed-reproduction factors that can contribute to invasive potential: fecundity, or how much seed is produced, and dispersal, or how readily those seeds spread, whether a few feet or much farther. In some cases, vegetative spread also matters because a species may expand through rhizomes, stolons, suckers, or other non-seed means. Lombardoni cited kudzu (Pueraria montana) as an extreme reminder of what can happen when a plant’s ability to spread is underestimated.
Traits the program avoids
The traits the program pursues vary greatly by genus, so Lombardoni focused on some it does not target. A prominent example is highly compact cultivars, which have proliferated in industry breeding because they look good in pots and ship efficiently. He said he would not rule out releasing a compact cultivar if a promising selection arose, but compactness is not something he actively seeks.
In this context, he defined compact as about 30 inches or shorter. He would not consider a 4-foot-tall cultivar bred from a species normally 5 or 6 feet tall to be very compact. There is a difference, he said, between reining in the size of an unruly species and releasing a cultivar half, or less, the height of the species it is bred from.
The program also avoids sterility, which in ornamental horticulture can take the form of double flowers. In those cases, additional petals may replace pistils and/or stamens, potentially reducing available pollen or making other floral resources less accessible to pollinators. More broadly, Lombardoni said, the program does not seek cultivars with traits that hinder ecological function.
Pollinator work and a model selection
Pollinator support is an important consideration for many home gardeners. Lombardoni hopes to collaborate with the Garden’s Science Department, which is partnered with Northwestern University, to study pollinator visitation to the program’s breeding selections and compare their performance with straight species. Such work could help clarify how the abundance and diversity of pollinator visitation compare between the two.
He pointed to Eutrochium maculatum ‘Summer Snow’ as a cultivar that encapsulates these points. Released about 10 years ago, it was bred from germplasm collected roughly 90 miles from the Garden. Although that germplasm came from three counties away, Lombardoni still considers ‘Summer Snow’ a native selection because its species is also native to the Garden’s county. At 5 feet tall, it is not significantly shorter than the straight species, and its highly upright stems bear white flowers that support pollinators from mid-to-late summer.
Aesthetics remain a major consideration when breeding perennials for the commercial market, especially how a plant looks in a pot, and ecological function may not always receive the same emphasis. Because the Chicago Botanic Garden is a nonprofit organization, Lombardoni said, its program is not seeking to release a certain number of cultivars each year or to maximize sales of each one. That lack of pressure allows it to breed perennials differently from many commercial programs. His hope, he said, is that gardens will not someday consist entirely of perennials 2 feet or shorter.
