Lighting

Mlazgar Appeals $9.25 Million Net Judgment in Hubbell Lighting Dispute

The Minnesota agency is seeking to pause collection and obtain summary reversal while a Fourth Circuit panel weighs its stay request.

Zeynep KayaNovember 15, 20265 min read0 views
An unmarked contract stack, a closed slide-deck folder and a tipped brass scale sit on a conference table in a dim lighting-agency office, with pendant fixtures glowing behind.

R.L. Mlazgar Associates is asking the Fourth Circuit to pause collection of a roughly $9.25 million net judgment while it appeals, and to overturn the underlying verdict without full briefing. HLI Solutions, the former Hubbell Lighting and now part of Current, urged the appeals court to reject both requests.

On Aug. 31, Judge Jacquelyn D. Austin awarded Hubbell Lighting $10,724,878 on its breach-of-contract counterclaim. Mlazgar won $1,478,848 under South Carolina's sales representative statute, half of it punitive, leaving the Minnesota agency owing about $9.25 million.

The automatic 30-day hold on collection expired Oct. 1. Mlazgar asked Austin in September to extend it and has not received a ruling. On Nov. 3, it took the request to Richmond, asking the Fourth Circuit to block collection until Feb. 18, 2027, and to allow its balance sheet to be filed under seal.

Mlazgar cites two sources of potential relief. Its fee petition seeking $3,843,818 and a request for $319,616 in prejudgment interest remain pending in Greenville and could reduce the net figure. It also faces a Jan. 19 trial in Minneapolis against Focal Point, where its lawyers say a large recovery “could assist” it in posting security.

Hubbell Lighting dismissed the agency's financial warnings as “ipse dixit,” an assertion offered without proof. It pointed to a 2010 South Carolina ruling that refused a stay despite the debtor's claimed inability to pay, warning that a judgment holder should not be forced to fund an appeal on the “unsupported hope” of later payment.

Trial exhibits give the financial argument context. In 2019, Mlazgar and Elan Lighting—the Wisconsin agency Mlazgar later acquired—represented Focal Point and sister company Kenall. Those lines generated about $333,000 and $149,000 in commissions. In the same year, Mlazgar earned about $941,000 in commissions representing Hubbell Lighting.

By those figures, the Focal Point and Kenall business was about half the size of the Hubbell Lighting relationship that produced the verdict. A Minneapolis award equal to one to three years of the Focal Point and Kenall commissions would land in the mid-six figures to low-seven figures—a fraction of the $9.25 million owed.

Alongside the stay request, Mlazgar filed a motion for summary reversal, a procedure that lets an appeals court discard a judgment without full briefing when the issues are “manifestly unsubstantial.” Courts typically use it when precedent has already settled a question. Mlazgar is seeking that relief after a nine-day jury trial and a $10.7 million verdict.

The agency argues that the exclusivity clause it breached is an unenforceable non-compete under South Carolina law, and that a separate contract provision bars Hubbell Lighting's lost-profit damages. Hubbell Lighting calls the motion “meritless and borders on frivolous,” says the district court rejected the liability argument three times, and notes that Mlazgar cited no case from any circuit summarily reversing a jury verdict.

The Cooper Lighting deck sits at the center of the causation dispute. Dated Oct. 9, 2020, it was sent by then-Cooper executive Shane Bickley under the subject line “Mlazgar Rollout.” It laid out a 30-day launch plan, including a step to “Execute plan to convert Hubbell stock positions at Mlazgar strongholds.”

The deck also called for a “Market Blitz” aimed at the top 20 contractors, distributors and specifiers, emphasizing customers with existing Hubbell Lighting projects, plus a promotion “to incentivize quick conversions from Hubbell.” Hubbell Lighting uses the deck to rebut Mlazgar's claim that its breach did not cause lost profits, writing that Mlazgar and Cooper “were plotting the very losses that HLI incurred even prior to the breach.”

Hubbell Lighting filed the Cooper deck under seal in Greenville last month; in Richmond, it is on the public docket. Mlazgar can reply before a three-judge panel takes up the stay. The panel could grant a temporary pause, deny it, or leave the matter to Judge Austin, who has had the September request for eight weeks.

For lighting industry participants, the case raises a broader question about the cost of ending an agency agreement. If exit carries such a high bar, and a misstep can run into the millions, more contracts in agency filing cabinets may draw fresh scrutiny. Mlazgar is counting on the Minneapolis case to prove its point, but it will need more than a good day there.